Coco Taqueria - Sleepy Hollow, New York

K VC

3.5
Returned yesterday during the Sleepy Hollow Street Fair, which was very popular and crowded. Other eateries had lines outside which was the same for Coco Taqueria.
Coco had a stand outside but had a limited menu so decided to order inside. It is a small place so was packed, also with people standing waiting for their order. I saw at least 10 tickets but also saw a lot of ready containers, but only one person sorting and bagging them. They should have anticipated that it would be busy and could have given him a partner. Instead, the cashier had to help clear the tickets so she had to stop taking orders for a good while. I give the staff up front credit bec they worked as fast as they can but didn’t seem flustered. Wait time from standing on line to getting our food was at least 45 min. Luckily we got seats while waiting for our order. Chimichanga was crispy by the edges, would have preferred the whole thing to be. Felt the portions were much smaller, less filling than our previous visit. Flavors still good.

Amanda

I really loved my lunch here the other day. We were in search of some good Mexican food and we found some! I’m always a sucker for a fried tortilla bowl so when I saw it on the menu I knew I needed to have it. We ordered the chorizo taco bowl and it was so so good. The fillings were perfection and the bowl was almost perfect! It was either a little over cooked or needed an oil change but overall it was great. We also ordered shrimp and chicken tacos. They were also both really good with a lot of meat. I’d love to see some additional toppings but what they had was good. We also ordered chips and nacho cheese because I never see nacho cheese on menus and needed it!

The inside is decorated in all things Coco the movie. It’s a medium/smallish restaurant but you could easily fit a group of 6. Our server was friendly. The parking on that street was a bit confusing as there were no meters but they have a sign inside making it easy to realize you need to pay and helps you figure out how which we really appreciated. Overall good experience and we’ll be back!

Geovanni Cruz

this place was such a nice spot in my travels to sleepy Hollow. Food was good and the service was wonderful. Next time I’m in the area I will have to try another item because what I had was tasty I can only imagine how good the rest of the menu is!

A C

The food is really amazing here. Went a year ago and it was great. Brought my family a year later and again amazing. True authentic Mexican flavor and the gentleman who served us was very kind.

La comida aquí es realmente increíble. Fui hace un año y fue genial. Traje a mi familia un año después y de nuevo increíble. Verdadero sabor mexicano auténtico y el caballero que nos sirvió fue muy amable.

jesse federbush

Love finding these small places. The tacos were amazing, I had the steak, son had the pork and wife had the Mahi. Everything was extremely flavor full, the guacamole was fresh and had a great flavor. Really small and very busy. Would 100% eat here again (without kids)! Thank you!

Marleny Lopez

Omg so good. I tried the baja fish, the carne asada and the taco alambre and they were delicious. My son is a picky eater he had the kids beef burrito and it was delicious as well. The flavors are so good and the tacos are filled not just with vegetables. I got full off 3 tacos. Best tacos I've had in years. Service was fast and friendly. My new favorite taco spot.

Jennifer Gold

Homey spot, easy, and friendly. Had a good taco here, but the tripe sopa was GREAT! Tripe was soft and tender, but also had a creamy texture, which was unique. I’ve had all types of tripe from different cuisines, and I would say, this one’s a keeper. I wanted 3 more bowls. Plus, service was wonderful! Definitely would eat here again when I’m in the neighborhood!!

EriCa Quinn

Ducked in here for a quick bite. It was a chilly day so we had the chicken tortilla soup. It was really good, authentically Mexican. The server was very kind. Fast service. Exceeded our expectations. Definitely recommend.